• About Us
    • Join CAPPS Email List
    • What is Private Postsecondary Education
    • About ICEPAC
  • News
    • Legislation / Advocacy
  • Events
    • CAPPS Legislative Policy Conference 2021
    • 37th Annual Conference
    • Educational Advisors ~ Event Calendar
  • Resources
    • Classifieds
    • Professional Online Training Center
    • State and Federal Resources
    • Accreditors
    • Boards
    • Associations
  • CAPPS Member Portal & Archives
    • CAPPS Membership Directory
    • Conference Archives
    • Webinar Archives
    • Workshop Archives
    • CAPPS Member Portal
      • CAPPS Legislative Watch
    • Featured Members
    • Select Allied or School Benefits – Why be a CAPPS Member?
      • School Membership Application & Renewal Form
      • Allied Membership Application & Renewal Form
  • Awards
    • CAPPS Memorial Scholarships
    • Excellence in Community Service Awards
    • CAPPS Hall of Fame STAR Awards
    • Norma Ford Financial Aid Professional of the Year
    • School of the Year
    • Allied Member of the Year
California Association of Private Postsecondary Schools                        
916-447-5500
Email
        Login
CAPPS
  • About Us
    • Join CAPPS Email List
    • What is Private Postsecondary Education
    • About ICEPAC
  • News
    • Legislation / Advocacy
  • Events
    • CAPPS Legislative Policy Conference 2021
    • 37th Annual Conference
    • Educational Advisors ~ Event Calendar
  • Resources
    • Classifieds
    • Professional Online Training Center
    • State and Federal Resources
    • Accreditors
    • Boards
    • Associations
  • CAPPS Member Portal & Archives
    • CAPPS Membership Directory
    • Conference Archives
    • Webinar Archives
    • Workshop Archives
    • CAPPS Member Portal
      • CAPPS Legislative Watch
    • Featured Members
    • Select Allied or School Benefits – Why be a CAPPS Member?
      • School Membership Application & Renewal Form
      • Allied Membership Application & Renewal Form
  • Awards
    • CAPPS Memorial Scholarships
    • Excellence in Community Service Awards
    • CAPPS Hall of Fame STAR Awards
    • Norma Ford Financial Aid Professional of the Year
    • School of the Year
    • Allied Member of the Year

News

  • Home
  • News
  • Battle brewing over DeVos’ delay of ‘borrower defense’ rules

Battle brewing over DeVos’ delay of ‘borrower defense’ rules

  • Posted by CAPPS
  • Date

POLITICO

Battle brewing over DeVos’ delay of ‘borrower defense’ rules

By MICHAEL STRATFORD

06/20/2017 10:00 AM EDT

Updated 06/20/2017 09:16 AM EDT

With help from Kimberly Hefling and Benjamin Wermund

BATTLE BREWING OVER DEVOS’ DELAY OF ‘BORROWER DEFENSE’ RULES: The Trump administration last week, in a highly-anticipated move, formally announced that it had halted implementation of the Education Department’s “borrower defense to repayment” package of regulations that were slated to take effect on July 1. But the legal fight over whether Education Secretary Betsy DeVos has the power to delay those rules is just getting started.

— Senate Democrats and at least one Democratic state attorney general have indicated they don’t believe DeVos has the authority to unilaterally put on hold regulations that were finalized by the previous administration. Massachusetts Attorney General Maura Healey has vowed to sue. Democratic Sens. Elizabeth Warren, Patty Murray, Sherrod Brown and Dick Durbin said in a letter earlier this month that the administration delaying the regulations would violate the law.

— The rules would have set a new standard for when defrauded student loan borrowers could cancel their debt, banned mandatory arbitration clauses and given the Education Department new powers to take action against schools it deemed financially risky The Obama administration finalized the regulations last June after a months-long rulemaking process. Congressional Republicans earlier this year took a pass on repealing the rules through the Congressional Review Act, the mechanism they used to scrap other regulations finalized during the waning months of the previous administration, including those governing teacher preparation programs and school accountability.

— In delaying the regulations, the Trump administration cited a legal challenge from a California for-profit college association, saying it would postpone the rules until that was resolved. The department said it had such power under section 705 of the Administrative Procedures Act, which allows an agency to postpone a regulation when “justice so requires,” while a rule is “pending judicial review.”

— But internal documents obtained by POLITICO show that the Trump administration wrestled with the precise rationale for delaying the rules. Before it settled on the Administrative Procedures Act section 705 rationale, the department considered writing a new “interim final rule” that pushed back the effective date of the rules by two years to July 2019. The department said in that May 25 draft notice that “the President’s appointees and designees need to delay the effective date of these regulations in order have adequate time to review them.” It also cited the rule’s estimated cost to taxpayers. The California for-profit college association filed its lawsuit on May 24.

— Dennis Cariello, a former deputy general counsel at the Education Department during the George W. Bush administration who represented for-profit colleges during negotiations over the rules, said the Trump administration was well within its authority under the Administrative Procedures Act to delay the rule. “It makes sense to slow this down and not allow the negative consequences of the rule to affect the higher education sector until a judge has ruled that it is, in fact, appropriate,” he said.

— Julie Miceli, a higher education attorney who served as deputy general counsel at the department during the Obama administration, said that the Trump administration clearly has the power to change any regulation by starting a new negotiated rulemaking process, as it has announced it will do for these rules. “So the question really is whether the agency is violating the APA if it fails to enforce the [borrower defense] rules in the interim,” she said, adding that student loan borrowers “will likely argue that not enforcing these rules during this extended interim period could potentially result in financial harm.”

— What’s up next: A federal judge on Wednesday will hold a hearing to discuss how to proceed with the lawsuit in light of the Trump administration’s delay of the regulations.

 

Tag:borrower defense, for-profit, trump

  • Share:
author avatar
CAPPS

Previous post

Department of Education’s Announcement Leaves Unanswered Questions Regarding Coming Gainful Employment Rule Deadline

Next post

3 Ways to Realign Higher Education With Today's Workforce

You may also like

Real Clear
Expanding Opportunities for Students is DeVos’s Legacy
20 January, 2021
Inside Higher Ed
Billions in Aid Head to Colleges
20 January, 2021
EducationDiveLogo
How Biden’s immigration plan would affect colleges
20 January, 2021

Search

Memorial Scholarship Information
Donate to ICEPAC
Become an Allied Member
Become a School Member
CAPPS Events

ABOUT US

  • What is Private Postsecondary Education
  • CAPPS Memorial Scholarships
  • Upcoming Conferences

MAILING ADDRESS:
California Association of
Private Postsecondary Schools
2520 Venture Oaks, Suite 170
Sacramento, CA  95833
info@cappsonline.org
www.cappsonline.org    

CappsOnlineMorpho Web Design.

2020 All Rights Reserved CappsOnline.org